<$BlogRSDURL$>
Proceeds from the ads below will be donated to the Bob Wuesthoff scholarship fund.

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

New Blog: SportsHubLA, And Meditations On The Necessity Of Vin Scully's Retirement

Brian Kamenetzky (I always have to double check spelling on that name — all those consonents!) asked if I would add his new effort, SportsHubLA, to the sidebar. Sure; they're not strictly baseball, but it's worth linking to if for no other reason than this piece asking whether Vin Scully should retire. No, say I:
The team he’s been loyal to for six decades has had a busload of Hall of Fame players going all the way back to Brooklyn, and Vin Scully is better at what he does than any of them ever were, including Jackie, Duke, Pee Wee and even Sandy.

But bless his heart, less than two months from his 80th birthday, Vinnie is losing it.

I know, I know. No one wants to hear it. No one wants to believe it. In the name of the Dodger Hammond organ, Nancy Bea and Farmer John himself, he’s Vinnie, for pete’s sake. The baritone voice, the poetic phrasing, the encyclopedic knowledge, the impeccable timing, the humor, the insight, the anecdotes, the wonderful stories woven seamlessly into the palette the artist paints. The Vinnie that Los Angeles loves like he’s family should call Dodger games for 57 more years and 57 more after that if he wants to. Heck, we’ll send a limo to pick him up.

Except I’m sitting here tonight, watching a meaningless Dodger-Giant game that Vinnie can still make meaningful, or at least watchable, and this star of all microphone stars is making so many mistakes on the air, I’m actually embarassed FOR him.

Omar Vizquel is Omar Valdez. The 1-0 pitch from David Wells is taken for strike three! A fastball is called a curve, a curve is a slider, a changeup is a fastball…it’s obvious that as 80 approaches, Vin can no longer call pitches because he’s having trouble simply seeing them.

I dunno. Maybe I just don't see it. Anybody who actively lobbied to get the players names back on their backs just can't be too bad.

Labels: ,


Comments:
Sacrilege! I am not even going to this guys blog to give him one of the hits he's probably trying to generate with this nonsense! Sure, Vinny might make a few mistakes here and there, but he is still head and shoulders above virtually any other announcer out there. I think he'll know when his time has come and have the decency to retire when he should. Until then, I will treasure every moment of his broadcasting. Vin Scully is the heart and soul of the Dodgers and things won't ever be the same when he is gone.
 
I agree with the fiend. Yeah, I've noticed that he slips up from time to time, but it's still a pleasure to hear him call a game. He still offers better insight than 99% of the commentators around, while also being among the best play-by-play men (I like Harry Kalas in Philadelphia, too).

And if the guy is going to nit-pick on Vin for getting a player's name wrong, he should be equally taken to task for not knowing that Dodger Stadium has a Baldwin organ, not a Hammond, and that's been the case for at least a decade, I'm sure.
 
It's a question that should be asked from time to time, but I can't think of a single broadcaster in the business who does a better job. When Vin thinks it's time, he'll let us know. Until that day, he's our treasure, flawed, perhaps, to enjoy.
 
I think he may have caught Vin in a bad game. I don't think he makes that many mistakes, and those that he does make are more than made up for by all the other stuff he brings to a broadcast.
 

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.



Newer›  ‹Older
This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?
Google

WWW 6-4-2